Surety Bonds Are Not Fair!



Why are some surety bonds better than others? Why can small ones be harder to get than big ones?


Construction companies are among a bonding company's most important clients. They are the source of Performance and Payment bonds which guarantee their construction contracts. For a bonding company (surety), these are probably the largest and most lucrative transactions. So why would the surety risk losing a client by giving tough terms on an obviously small bond?

There are many different types of surety bonds, and contractors may need a variety of them: Bid bond, performance, payment, maintenance, license, permit, court, are a few. In this article we will discuss why the big ones (large dollar amount) can be easier to get than small ones - even for the same applicant.

The answer to this question lies in the nature of the obligation, not the dollar amount. A good way to illustrate this is to compare a Performance bond to a Wage and Welfare bond.

Performance Bond

Performance and Payment (P&P) bonds concern construction contracts. They guarantee that the applicant will perform the project in accordance with all aspects of the written contract, and they will pay the related bills for suppliers of labor and material.

Wage and Welfare Bond

This type of bond is needed by union contractors (companies that employ union workers.) The W&W bond guarantees that the construction company will pay the union wage rate as required and make the related periodic contributions to the union benefit plans such as the pension and health insurance program.

It's Just Not Fair!

P&P bonds range in amount from a couple hundred thousand dollars to tens of millions, whereas a W&W bond is often under $100,000. So why can it be easier to get the big one? Why can a $500,000 performance bond be easier to get than a $50,000 union bond?

The answer lies in the nature of the obligation - and the worst case scenarios.

Let's assume the contractor goes out of business. With a performance bond, the surety steps into the contractors shoes. They must make arrangements to complete the project in accordance with the contract. The beneficiary of the performance bond (aka the obligee, the owner of the contract) continues to pay out the remainder of the contract amount as work progresses. Now they pay the surety performing the completion. This is called the "unpaid contract amount." Even if the contractor falls flat and has no money personally, the unpaid contract amount is a resource the surety can depend on - and hopefully avoid a net loss on the claim.

The union bond is a promise to pay funds at a future date. It is a financial guarantee - the toughest type of surety obligation. The underwriters will look into their crystal ball... Oh, sorry, we don't have one.

The surety is guaranteeing the future solvency of the construction company, not an easy task. And if they are wrong, if the contractor cannot make their union payments because they have no money, then there is no money for the surety, either.

Q. Who is likely to pay the wage and welfare claim?

A. The surety (a net loss)

It is the tough nature of some small bonds (wage and welfare, release of lien, supersedeas) that makes them exceptionally hard to get - often requiring full collateral. On the other hand, the surety may give the same applicant a $300,000 performance bond based primarily on just their credit report!

Bottom line: It just ain't fair, but we never promised it would be - because the nature of the obligations differ. That is the deciding factor, even more than the dollar amount of the bond.

Steve Golia is Marketing Manager for FIA Surety, a NJ based insurance company providing Bid, Performance, Site and Subdivision Bonds since 1979.

Steve: 856-304-7348

FIA Surety / First Indemnity of America Insurance Company

Visit us Click!

Post a Comment

Informations From: Taun17

Previous Post Next Post
  • Shouldn't Our Public Officials Learn From History? 6 Examples

    By Richard Brody Wouldn't it be, in the public's best interests, if, our elected officials, learned key lessons, from history, in order to avoid, making the same mistakes, over - and - over, again? Unfortunately, we often observe, ill - conceived, ideas, programs, and legislation/ laws, caused, ei... Readmore

  • A Population Denied

    By Dr. Tim G Williams As with all things seasons come and go and we all get old. Some age with dignity and grace while others succumb to illness or injury. It is these poor souls who suffer a more debilitating fate. In this the spring of 2018 when science and medicine have reached new heights ther... Readmore

  • Understanding Worship

    By Paul W Hoffmaster Worship is probably one of the most misunderstood words in the Christian vocabulary. Many churches promote singing and emotional energy as worship. "Worship teams" strive to energize the assembled Believers into a conglomerate of "worshippers." Much of the music is selected to... Readmore

  • Why Grief Was Made for Hope

    By Steve Wickham Some statements seem ridiculous when we first read them. Perhaps the title seems bizarre. But there are always truths in life we have no idea about. Then, sometimes, God uses the circumstances in our lives to break through and cause us to learn something new. This is a hope that's... Readmore

  • Seven Ways Tears Beat Fears

    By Steve Wickham This article is brought to you today by the concept of tears of depth when the heart is moved. A vision God gave me in those tears: there are multiple ways tears help us to feel alive every day and remove fear. Tears to be touched. In worshipping God, for the moment of being touch... Readmore

  • Knowledge Is The Most Powerful Weapon

    By Sergei VanBellinghen Knowledge is the most powerful weapon you are ever going to have at your disposal. It is not a gun, a sword or a bomb because the strongest instrument you will have if you really want to make a change is what you learn. So, wherever you are right now in life, I want you to ... Readmore

  • The Abuse Was Passed From One Generation To Another

    By Oliver JR Cooper Over the years, I have had many conversations with my mother about what her childhood was like. This wasn't simply because I wanted to know what this time in her life was like; it was because I wanted to find out why she behaved the way she did. As the years went by she settled... Readmore

  • Why Hypnosis Is Better Than Caffeine

    By William T Batten I don't need to tell you that feeling tired is rough. It affects everything you are, including your judgement and willpower. In theory, going to bed early should be easy when you're exhausted. And yet, it's somehow easy to stay up to surf the web or binge-watch TV. It's easy to... Readmore

  • Are You Building A Silo With No Doors?

    By Janet Christy Have you recently been turned down for funding? Did you have a potential partner say, "Don't call us, we'll call you? Did you recently get a research report that you felt was incomplete? The bad news is it may have been your fault because you have built, or appear to be constructin... Readmore

  • What I'm Thinking As They Drive Off in the Distance

    By Steve Wickham Having said our goodbyes, the car reversed out of the driveway, last waves were had, forward the wheels rolled down the road, before turning the corner and going out of view. The loaned reality of sorrow struck once more. It won't always be like this. I won't always have the privil... Readmore