Surety Bonds Are Not Fair!



Why are some surety bonds better than others? Why can small ones be harder to get than big ones?


Construction companies are among a bonding company's most important clients. They are the source of Performance and Payment bonds which guarantee their construction contracts. For a bonding company (surety), these are probably the largest and most lucrative transactions. So why would the surety risk losing a client by giving tough terms on an obviously small bond?

There are many different types of surety bonds, and contractors may need a variety of them: Bid bond, performance, payment, maintenance, license, permit, court, are a few. In this article we will discuss why the big ones (large dollar amount) can be easier to get than small ones - even for the same applicant.

The answer to this question lies in the nature of the obligation, not the dollar amount. A good way to illustrate this is to compare a Performance bond to a Wage and Welfare bond.

Performance Bond

Performance and Payment (P&P) bonds concern construction contracts. They guarantee that the applicant will perform the project in accordance with all aspects of the written contract, and they will pay the related bills for suppliers of labor and material.

Wage and Welfare Bond

This type of bond is needed by union contractors (companies that employ union workers.) The W&W bond guarantees that the construction company will pay the union wage rate as required and make the related periodic contributions to the union benefit plans such as the pension and health insurance program.

It's Just Not Fair!

P&P bonds range in amount from a couple hundred thousand dollars to tens of millions, whereas a W&W bond is often under $100,000. So why can it be easier to get the big one? Why can a $500,000 performance bond be easier to get than a $50,000 union bond?

The answer lies in the nature of the obligation - and the worst case scenarios.

Let's assume the contractor goes out of business. With a performance bond, the surety steps into the contractors shoes. They must make arrangements to complete the project in accordance with the contract. The beneficiary of the performance bond (aka the obligee, the owner of the contract) continues to pay out the remainder of the contract amount as work progresses. Now they pay the surety performing the completion. This is called the "unpaid contract amount." Even if the contractor falls flat and has no money personally, the unpaid contract amount is a resource the surety can depend on - and hopefully avoid a net loss on the claim.

The union bond is a promise to pay funds at a future date. It is a financial guarantee - the toughest type of surety obligation. The underwriters will look into their crystal ball... Oh, sorry, we don't have one.

The surety is guaranteeing the future solvency of the construction company, not an easy task. And if they are wrong, if the contractor cannot make their union payments because they have no money, then there is no money for the surety, either.

Q. Who is likely to pay the wage and welfare claim?

A. The surety (a net loss)

It is the tough nature of some small bonds (wage and welfare, release of lien, supersedeas) that makes them exceptionally hard to get - often requiring full collateral. On the other hand, the surety may give the same applicant a $300,000 performance bond based primarily on just their credit report!

Bottom line: It just ain't fair, but we never promised it would be - because the nature of the obligations differ. That is the deciding factor, even more than the dollar amount of the bond.

Steve Golia is Marketing Manager for FIA Surety, a NJ based insurance company providing Bid, Performance, Site and Subdivision Bonds since 1979.

Steve: 856-304-7348

FIA Surety / First Indemnity of America Insurance Company

Visit us Click!

Post a Comment

Informations From: Taun17

Previous Post Next Post
  • How to Improve Team Culture and Attitude

    How to Improve Team Culture and Attitude By Derek Parola The three musts that coaches must do to improve a team culture. Those three things are getting the players to buy in to the system, creating an accepting environment, and establishing a hard-working expectation. Getting players to buy into th... Readmore

  • The "Experts" Are Getting Crypto All Wrong

    The "Experts" Are Getting Crypto All Wrong By Ted Bauman Bitcoin peaked about a month ago, on December 17, at a high of nearly $20,000. As I write, the cryptocurrency is under $11,000... a loss of about 45%. That's more than $150 billion in lost market cap. Cue much hand-wringing and gnashing of te... Readmore

  • Those Great Pumpkins

    Those Great Pumpkins By Dale Phillip Pumpkins have been present in North America since 7000 B.C. and probably had their beginnings in Mexico. A member of the squash family, the name means "large melon" in Greek (pepon), which the French called pompon. It is believed that early civilizations consume... Readmore

  • The Different Kinds of General Surgeries Offered at Hospitals

    The Different Kinds of General Surgeries Offered at Hospitals By Shalini Madhav General surgery is a specialty, which focuses on different abdominal contents like the bile ducts, the appendix, the gallbladder, the pancreas, liver, colon, small bowel, stomach, and esophagus. Most times, it involves ... Readmore

  • We Have to Safeguard the Health and Well Being of Future Generations

    We Have to Safeguard the Health and Well Being of Future Generations By Kate Kaya In US there are government recognized agencies which certify the ecosystem safe buildings. Such certified buildings normally use up to 40% less energy compared to the accepted buildings. Keeping this concept in mind h... Readmore

  • Relationships: Can Someone's Unmet Childhood Needs Cause Them To Expect Too Much From Others?

    Relationships: Can Someone's Unmet Childhood Needs Cause Them To Expect Too Much From Others? By Oliver JR Cooper Before one gets into a relationship, they can have a rough idea about the kind of person who they want to be with. Along with this, there can be what they expect to receive when they ar... Readmore

  • Critical Thinking: Does A Woman Need To Seek Professional Help If She Believes That All Men Are Bad?

    Critical Thinking: Does A Woman Need To Seek Professional Help If She Believes That All Men Are Bad? By Oliver JR Cooper In today's world, it appears to be perfectly acceptable for a woman in the public eye to bash men. She can say all kinds of things that will basically amount to men being less-th... Readmore

  • I Was Full Of Self-Doubt

    I Was Full Of Self-Doubt By Oliver JR Cooper Before I started writing articles, I had been on the path for around seven years. During this time, I had put a lot of effort into trying to understand myself and why my life was the way it was. So, when I started writing, it wasn't as though I just woke... Readmore

  • What Can You Do With Pepper Jelly?

    What Can You Do With Pepper Jelly? By Amanda J Hales How would you like a nice bowl of creamy ice cream topped with pepper jelly? What? Wait! Pepper jelly on ice cream? Why, yes, as it gives you a sweet-heat treat neatly atop that cool and creamy dessert. Why go for chocolate sauce when you can try... Readmore

  • The One and Only Pepper Jelly

    The One and Only Pepper Jelly By Amanda J Hales Remember when jam and jelly used to be sweet? It was, and still is made with fruits and people have come up with interesting combinations to put together in order for us to have a vast variety. Jelly is something most of us have had at one time or ano... Readmore