Surety Bonds Are Not Fair!



Why are some surety bonds better than others? Why can small ones be harder to get than big ones?


Construction companies are among a bonding company's most important clients. They are the source of Performance and Payment bonds which guarantee their construction contracts. For a bonding company (surety), these are probably the largest and most lucrative transactions. So why would the surety risk losing a client by giving tough terms on an obviously small bond?

There are many different types of surety bonds, and contractors may need a variety of them: Bid bond, performance, payment, maintenance, license, permit, court, are a few. In this article we will discuss why the big ones (large dollar amount) can be easier to get than small ones - even for the same applicant.

The answer to this question lies in the nature of the obligation, not the dollar amount. A good way to illustrate this is to compare a Performance bond to a Wage and Welfare bond.

Performance Bond

Performance and Payment (P&P) bonds concern construction contracts. They guarantee that the applicant will perform the project in accordance with all aspects of the written contract, and they will pay the related bills for suppliers of labor and material.

Wage and Welfare Bond

This type of bond is needed by union contractors (companies that employ union workers.) The W&W bond guarantees that the construction company will pay the union wage rate as required and make the related periodic contributions to the union benefit plans such as the pension and health insurance program.

It's Just Not Fair!

P&P bonds range in amount from a couple hundred thousand dollars to tens of millions, whereas a W&W bond is often under $100,000. So why can it be easier to get the big one? Why can a $500,000 performance bond be easier to get than a $50,000 union bond?

The answer lies in the nature of the obligation - and the worst case scenarios.

Let's assume the contractor goes out of business. With a performance bond, the surety steps into the contractors shoes. They must make arrangements to complete the project in accordance with the contract. The beneficiary of the performance bond (aka the obligee, the owner of the contract) continues to pay out the remainder of the contract amount as work progresses. Now they pay the surety performing the completion. This is called the "unpaid contract amount." Even if the contractor falls flat and has no money personally, the unpaid contract amount is a resource the surety can depend on - and hopefully avoid a net loss on the claim.

The union bond is a promise to pay funds at a future date. It is a financial guarantee - the toughest type of surety obligation. The underwriters will look into their crystal ball... Oh, sorry, we don't have one.

The surety is guaranteeing the future solvency of the construction company, not an easy task. And if they are wrong, if the contractor cannot make their union payments because they have no money, then there is no money for the surety, either.

Q. Who is likely to pay the wage and welfare claim?

A. The surety (a net loss)

It is the tough nature of some small bonds (wage and welfare, release of lien, supersedeas) that makes them exceptionally hard to get - often requiring full collateral. On the other hand, the surety may give the same applicant a $300,000 performance bond based primarily on just their credit report!

Bottom line: It just ain't fair, but we never promised it would be - because the nature of the obligations differ. That is the deciding factor, even more than the dollar amount of the bond.

Steve Golia is Marketing Manager for FIA Surety, a NJ based insurance company providing Bid, Performance, Site and Subdivision Bonds since 1979.

Steve: 856-304-7348

FIA Surety / First Indemnity of America Insurance Company

Visit us Click!

Post a Comment

Informations From: Taun17

Previous Post Next Post
  • Go for Your Dreams and Move Past the Naysayers

    By Chris Atley It's amazing the stories we create around what someone else is doing especially when it pertains to following their dreams. I realized this recently with my son following a big dream. We've been looking at a bunch of different baseball clubs - as he has some pretty hefty dreams - and... Readmore

  • Image-Obsessed: Can Someone Try To Look Perfect When They Feel Worthless?

    By Oliver JR Cooper If a woman wanted to change her appearance in the past, she may have had a boob job. Nowadays, this is just one of a number of procedures that a woman can have to change how she looks. Plenty of Options If she isn't happy with her weight, she could have fat removed, and this wil... Readmore

  • Mr Trump, Keep Your Campaign Promises If You Expect to Be Re-Elected

    By Norton Nowlin When a Presidential candidate, any Presidential candidate, campaigns and makes promises to those U.S. citizens of the national electorate who support him, or her, and end-up voting for that candidate, those voters expect that person to make good on those campaign promises. Currentl... Readmore

  • Loyalty Makes You Family

    By Sergei VanBellinghen It hardly comes as a surprise that blood makes you related, but loyalty makes you family. Growing up, I always saw all of my relatives tear each other apart or taking sides instead of sticking together. And I am sure many of you can relate to this. So, I realized a long time... Readmore

  • Fight Instinct: Do Some People's Childhood Set Them Up To Disconnect From Their Fight Instinct?

    By Oliver JR Cooper No matter where someone lives on this planet, they are going to need to be able to stand their ground and to protect themselves. What this will do is stop them from being walked over by other people. Now, this is not to say that everyone who one will come across will have the de... Readmore

  • Punctuality As the Key

    By Omonegho Ugheoke Punctuality is the characteristic of being able to complete a required task or fulfill an obligation before or at a previously designated time. "Punctual" is often used synonymously with "on time". It is also acceptable that punctual can also, be related to talking about grammar... Readmore

  • Fake News: Historical Revisionism and the Culture of Misinformation

    By Ewin Gavanzo Who remembers opening up their history textbook after a lengthy summer vacation hoping for jolly tales about humanity's journey to the present day, only to be bombarded by depressing information about the malevolent Dictators of the 20th century? Who knew that the evil Mao Tse-tung ... Readmore

  • 7 Reasons Voters Continue Supporting Public Officials, Despite Their Flaws

    By Richard Brody One of the realities of the American electorate is, they often, seem, to want, to be fooled, and buy - into, the rhetoric, and, often - empty promises, made by politicians, when they are running, for office. I've often believed in the adage, One must never over - estimate, the immi... Readmore

  • Artificial Intelligence and the Economy in the 21st Century

    By Martin Hahn Artificial intelligence is a driving business force in this fast changing 21st century. AI is no longer an implausible futuristic vision, but a stark reality that is disrupting businesses worldwide. In the 21st century, companies are forced to rethink traditional market approaches an... Readmore

  • It's Not About the Guns

    By Ed Kugler The idea of using every crisis to move your cause forward comes from Rahm Emanuel who said, "You never want a serious crisis to go to waste. And what I mean by that is an opportunity to do things you think you could not do before." He is the Left hugging Mayor of Chicago. And his fell... Readmore